Without enabling legislation, NSW Health & Sydney Local Health District cannot record as revenue anything received from quarantined travellers- With legislation, NSW Health & SLHD cannot record as revenue a fine or penalty collected and enforced by Victor Dominello's Revenue NSW

 by Ganesh Sahathevan 



                            SLHD CEO Teresa Anderson AM  has ultimate responsibility for signing 
                             off SLHD's financial statements 




The refusal by  Ministers Victor Dominello and Brad Hazzard to provide any clarification of the legislation that they are relying on to collect quarantine fees means that NSW Health & Sydney Local Health District cannot record as revenue anything received from quarantined travellers. The absence of enabling legislation adds to the accounting nightmare SLHD Chief Executive Teresa Andersen must confront, given her responsibility for the preparation of the SLHD's accounts, which must then be tabled in the NSW Parliament. 

Even if there is enabling legislation (and there is so far no evidence that there is) the treatment of that cash inflow is problematic given Dominello's treatment of that cash flow as a penalty or fine over which his Revenue NSW has control. 









An invoice for a fee that is a penalty: Dominello's Revenue NSW will issue a statement of claim against anyone who seeks to challenge Hazzard's Quarantine Fee invoice






 by Ganesh Sahathevan 

This writer has been informed in writing by  Minister for Digital Victor Dominello's Revenue NSW officers that anyone wishing to challenge Health Minister Brad Hazzard's  Quarantine Fee Invoice will be issued a statement of claim by Revenue NSW.

That turns what has been described as a fee for services provided anyone who is required to be quarantined into a penalty. The invoice issued by Ministers Hazzard and Dominello for quarantine fees has therefore become much like a penalty or fine for speeding or some other traffic infringement.

How NSW Health accounts for the above in its own books remains a mystery. 




TO BE READ WITH 


October 01, 2021

 by   Ganesh Sahathevan 

                                                 

                                                        Brad Hazzard

                                           

                     Victor Dominello 


NSW Health is in charge of administering  NSW's COVID hotel quarantine system for arrivals by air. Those who have been quarantined for the mandatory 14 days are invoiced for their hotel stay by Sydney Local Health District (SLHD), which is part of NSW Health. The minister ultimately responsible is the NSW Minister For Health Brad HAzzard.

 

The invoice however is issued, and enforced, by Revenue NSW, and the minister ultimately responsible for that is Victor Dominello, who likes to be known as the Minister For Digital. 


Additionally, any queries about the invoice sent SLHD are directed to Revenue NSW.In fact, SLHD has informed this writer that it has been directed by NSW Health to do so, and cannot answer any queries about the particulars of its own invoice.In other words, the parties to the invoice cannot speak to each other; the person to whom the invoice is issued can only speak with Revenue NSW NSW with regards any concerns about the invoice. 


If the invoice is not paid when it falls due, Revenue NSW will pursue the matter with the help of debt collectors. Again, NSW Health and SLHD does not get involved.


All of the above raises accounting issues for SLHD Chief Executive, Teresa Anderson, who has ultimate responsible for SLHD's financial statements, which must be prepared, signed off by her, and then consolidated into NSW Health's financial statements. The individual and consolidated statements must then be tabled in Parliament by the Brad Hazzard.


However, without actual control of the revenue, it is hard to see what Ms Andersen might be accounting for. And that is not all; SLHD incurs costs in administering the hotel quarantine system, even if it has not control of the revenue. It is in a position where the cash is going out, but there may not be anything coming in. 


Questions about the above were put to Ms Andersen, but she has refused to provide answers. Meanwhile a large cash income , if not, cash deficit might be developing at SLHD, impairing its ability to provide health services to the people of Sydney. 

END 


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Ben Robert-Smith : How was Justice Anthony Besanko of the Federal Court able to find that the crime of murder has a civil twin, which can be determined on a balance of probabilities

Image
 by Ganesh Sahathevam                                                                                                                  The Hon Justice Anthony Besanko Media reports about the Ben Robert-Smith defamation matter  have at least given the impression, if not asserted,  that Justice Anthony Besanko of the Federal Court found  that Robert-Smith had committed murder. Most if not all reports have been at pains to stress that the finding was based on a balance of probabilities, and not beyond a reasonable doubt, for the matter was a civil and not criminal matter.  However,  reading his summary one can immediately see that Justice Besanko  found not that Roberts-Smith had committed murder but that the " respondents had, (on  a balance of probabilities) established the substantial truth"  that  Roberts-Smith had committed murder.  However, murder is a  crime and a finding of murder in a criminal court (which is the court in which crimes like murder can be determined!) inv
Read more

Who authorised former NSW Police Commissioner Mick Fuller to say anything about the Berejiklian era quarantine fee and why? Fuller's notice confirms suspicion that NSW Berejiklian government had no basis to impose the quarantine fee, nor quarantine persons who were COVID negative 

Image
 by Ganesh Sahathevan      Premier Gladys Berejiklian with NSW Police Commissioner Mick Fuller and Brigadier Mick             Garraway Who authorised former  NSW Police Commissioner Mick Fuller  to say anything about the  Berejiklian era  quarantine fee and why? Fuller's issuance of his  COVID  quarantine notice, and subsequent silence, would seem to confirm suspicions raised on this blog that NSW's Berejiklian government had no basis to impose its quarantine fee. Fuller's conduct also adds to suspicion that the Berejiklian government did not have the authority, even under its COVID emergency powers, to quarantine persons who were COVID negative. International arrivals had to test negative for COVID before boarding their flights to Sydney, and tests had to be administered within 72 hours of departure. Quarantine on arrival of those who exhibited no COVID symptoms was quite likely unnecessary. It did, of course help bolster Gladys Berejiklian's approval ratings. TO BE RE
Read more

Revenue NSW COVID Quarantine Fee payment demand notices suggest that Police Commissioner Mick Fuller breached the law with his demand for quarantine fees

Image
 By Ganesh Sahathevan  Anyone who has received a Revenue NSW Quarantine Fee demand for payment notice  will be familiar with these words that are contained in the notice: What is the quarantine service fee? A mandatory quarantine service fee applies to all travellers arriving in New South Wales (NSW) who are required to quarantine as part of the public health order. Mandatory quarantine is needed to stop the spread. of COVID-19 in NSW The qurantine fee has been charged pursuant to Section 70 of  the NSW Health Act. However, as previously reported, that section does not permit any imposition of mandatory fees.  However, in apparent defiance of Section 70 of the Health Act, Fuller issued a notice   in which he said  that Revenue NSW " will be charging a mandatory quarantine fee". TOE BE READ WITH  Former NSW Police Commissioner Mick Fuller said in his notice that Revenue NSW " will be charging a mandatory quarantine fee" - Former NSW Ministers Hazzard, Tudehope insis
Read more