Has Dan Andrews rejected Professor Tony Blakely's advice on ideological grounds? Blakely and Nick Wilson were among the few who provided expert analysis and commentary on the matter of the costs of the lockdown.

 by Ganesh Sahathevan 

Has Dan Andrews rejected Professor Tony Blakely's advice on ideological grounds? Blakely and Nick Wilson were among the  few who provided expert analysis and commentary on the matter of the costs of the lockdown. 

Daniel Andrews and the like ignored costs,and attempted to overcome that deficiency in their policy making processes by repeating , mantra like, the assertion that unless the "health issues" were eradicated or at least controlled, there would be nu economy.

The very heading of the Blakely-Wilson analysis ,  THE MATHS AND ETHICS OF MINIMISING COVID-19 DEATHS, would be anathema to Andrews. Additionally Andrews is probably concerned that if he adopts  Blakely's more recent advice that a lockdown s not necessary, his error in ordering the first lockdown in March-June may be seen to be a grave error, that continues to cost Victoria and Australia very many billions.

TO BE READ WITH 







Dan Andrews has ignored other modelling and advice from Melbourne University that does not fit his narrative-May also be misleading public when he says modelling based on thousands of scenarios gives him "only one choice".



September 05, 2020






by Ganesh Sahathevan

                                    

                                                              “Daniel Andrews Is Doing An Excellent Job,” Says China’s President






The following was reported by The Age on 6 September 2020: 

Melbourne is likely to remain in stage four lockdown until well into October, after the Victorian government commissioned modelling showing that releasing restrictions too soon risks an explosion of coronavirus cases before Christmas.


University of Melbourne professor of epidemiology Tony Blakely, one of the authors of the modelling, said there were two ways the model could be "beaten".
He said NSW had performed vastly better than Victoria in both its contact tracing and infectious diseases control protocols in hospitals and aged care settings. If Victoria improved these two aspects of its pandemic response, the state could record fewer than 25 daily cases more quickly than the model predicts and the state could also limit the increase in cases more effectively once stage four restrictions are eased.
Despite that modelling and advice Andrews went away and commissioned even more research which seems to be better aligned to his "tough" measures: 


"This is not a 50-50 choice. The modelling that [Deputy Chief Health Officer] Alan [Cheng] will speak to in a moment indicates that if we open up too fast then we have a very high likelihood, a very high likelihood that we are not really opening up at all. We are just beginning a third wave.

“I want to get the place open, and I want to keep it open,” Mr Andrews said "There is no choice for us, there is only one option.
"There is an enormous amount of modelling going on at the moment, that does take quite some time — literally thousands of scenarios are run through various computers and processes."

There would therefore be a range of options. To say that " there is only one option" is to mislead.The range of options allows flexibility in what measures are imposed, and how they are imposed.
This is a case of cherry picking the option that best suits a political agenda. The public should be told what other options the modelling suggests.
Recall then, that the modelling can be beaten. 
END 



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Sydney is not Soweto, its Asian migrants are not coloureds, or persons of colour - South African Australian Judge Angus Morkel Stewart's decision in Faruqi v Hanson an insult to anyone who is not white

Image
 by Ganesh Sahathevan  In the recent Federal Court Australia decision in   Faruqi v Hanson   Mr Justice Angus Morkel Stewart (Stewart J)  found at [242]: I am comfortably satisfied that both groups of people in Australia that I have identified, being persons of colour who are migrants or of relatively recent migrant heritage and persons of colour who are Muslim, are reasonably likely, in all the circumstances, to have been offended (ie profoundly and seriously), insulted, humiliated and intimidated by Senator (Pauline ) Hanson’s tweet. The case concerned   a tweet  that One Nation leader Pauline Hanson directed at  Deputy Greens leader Senator  Mehreen Faruqi. Mehreen is Pakistani Muslim who continues to advocate for Pakistan as a senator of the Senate, Parliament Of Australia.  Senator Hanson wrote in her tweet "piss off back to Pakistan" after Senator Faruqi commented on the death of Queen Elizabeth II. While Stewart J's has hand...
Read more

Ex NSW LPAB Executive Officer Louise Pritchard ,subject of queries from The Australian, hired by Sydney University since early 2019 -NSW LPAB has never explained her departure, UYSD the reasons for her appointment

Image
  by Ganesh Sahathevan  In January 2019 The Australian reported:  The body overseen by Chief Justice Tom Bathurst responsible for deciding who can practise law in NSW relied on a wildly defamatory Malaysian blog depicting ABC journalists, former British prime minister Tony Blair, financier George Soros and others as part of a global conspiracy when deciding to deny a would-be solicitor a certificate to practise. Chief Justice Bathurst and Legal Practitioner Admission Board executive officer Louise Pritchard declined to answer The Australian’s questions about how the article came into the board’s hands and why its members felt the conspiracy-laden material could be relied upon as part of a decision to deny Sydney man Ganesh Sahathevan admission as a lawyer. Nor would either say which of the 10 members of the LPAB, three of whom are serving NSW Supreme Court judges, was on the deciding panel. Ms Pritchard has left her role at the LPAB since The Australian began making inqui...
Read more

Strata managers' aversion to contact with tenants can leave strata managers exposed to personal liability

Image
 by Ganesh Sahathevan      Advice for living in, or buying into, a strata community Strata managers are employed to manage strata schemes which are often home to renters as well as owners. However, in evasion of that which they are paid to do there are instances where strata managers have attempted  to evade their duties by refusing to  deal with tenants.   Even this writer can recall an instance where the strata manager warned that it was against the law for tenants to contact him directly.  The instances where strata managers have refused to deal with tenants occur when the issues raised concern fairly pedestrian maintenance issues, for example blocked plumbing and the like. Having said that, tenants do actually have a legal right to a great many things, including being informed (and presumably make representations) when strata schemes consider re-development. Strata managers who seek to stand in place of strata committees  are even more e...
Read more